What Should Medical Practices Include in Medical Director Agreements to Reduce Compliance Risk?
"We have a physician serving as a medical director for our practice. What should be included in the agreement so we can show the arrangement is legitimate and reduce Stark and Anti-Kickback risk?"
A medical director agreement should do much more than state that a physician will provide “medical director services.” A strong medical director agreement should answer four basic questions:
Medical director arrangements deserve particular attention when the physician is also in a position to refer patients or generate federal healthcare program business for the entity paying them. Depending on the circumstances, the arrangement may need to satisfy a Stark Law exception, be evaluated under the federal Anti-Kickback Statute, or both.
CMS has clarified important Stark concepts such as fair market value, commercial reasonableness, and compensation that takes into account the volume or value of referrals. OIG likewise warns that fair market value alone does not make an arrangement automatically compliant with the Anti-Kickback Statute.
These elements matter because the government can look beyond the title on the contract and examine how the relationship actually operates. A signed document labeled “Medical Director Agreement” does not by itself make an arrangement compliant.
Start With a Legitimate Need for a Medical Director
Before drafting compensation terms, ask why the position exists. Your practice should be able to explain what responsibilities require physician oversight and why those duties aren’t already being performed as part of another position.
Depending on the organization, legitimate medical director responsibilities might involve clinical oversight, quality improvement, policy development, staff education, utilization review, safety initiatives, credentialing support, or regulatory responsibilities.
The exact duties will differ by organization. What matters is that the position reflects a real operational need, not simply a reason to make payments to a physician who happens to be an important referral source.
Define the Services in Detail
Avoid a one-sentence provision that says: “Physician shall provide medical director services as requested.”
That tells you very little about what the practice is purchasing. Instead, the agreement should describe the responsibilities with enough detail that someone reviewing it later could understand what the physician was expected to do.
For example, the agreement might address responsibilities such as reviewing clinical policies, participating in quality meetings, overseeing a particular service line, reviewing clinical protocols, conducting staff education, or addressing specified patient-safety issues.
Make sure to define the exact nature of the services rather than relying on the generic phrase “medical director services.”
Specify How Much Time the Services Require
If the arrangement expects the physician to provide a particular amount of time, document that expectation. Your agreement might specify an expected number of hours per month, required meetings, on-site responsibilities, remote responsibilities, or another reasonable description of the physician’s commitment.
The point isn’t to create artificial time requirements. It is to make sure the compensation and responsibilities make sense together.
If you are paying a physician for 20 hours of medical director work every month, your records should be able to support the fact that there is enough legitimate work to justify approximately that commitment.
Don’t Pay for a Title
One of the easiest medical director arrangements to question is one where the physician receives a monthly payment but nobody can explain what the physician actually does. A title alone isn’t a service.
If the physician is being paid $3,000 each month, someone in your organization should be able to identify the responsibilities performed during that period.
Connect Every Part of the Agreement
Business Need → Responsibilities → Time/Deliverables → Compensation → Documentation
When one of those pieces is missing, the arrangement becomes harder to defend.
Put the Arrangement in Writing
Medical director relationships should not operate through vague verbal understandings. It’s important to have applicable physician compensation arrangements in writing and signed by the parties.
The precise Stark requirements can depend on the exception being relied upon, and current Stark rules contain flexibility in some areas concerning documentation and signatures. That does not mean your practice should intentionally operate without a written agreement.
From a practical compliance standpoint, a current written agreement gives you a clear record of what was approved. It also reduces disagreements later about responsibilities, compensation, timing, and expectations.
Make Sure Everyone Actually Signs It
This sounds basic, but incomplete contracts are common. Your compliance review should confirm that the final agreement was executed—not simply that someone saved a draft to the contract folder.
Keep the completed agreement in a central location and establish a system for tracking renewal and expiration dates. Don’t depend on someone remembering where the signed copy is three years later when the practice receives an audit request.
Clearly Describe Compensation
The agreement should make the compensation methodology understandable.
For example, state whether the physician receives an annual amount, monthly amount, hourly compensation, or another permitted methodology.
Avoid vague language such as: “Physician will receive compensation as mutually agreed by the parties.”
That makes it difficult to determine what was actually approved. The agreement and supporting documentation should allow your practice to explain how compensation was established and why it is appropriate for the services being provided.
Evaluate Fair Market Value
Fair market value is an important concept in many physician compensation arrangements.
CMS’s current Stark guidance specifically identifies fair market value as one of the fundamental concepts addressed in the physician self-referral regulations.
Depending on the significance or complexity of the arrangement, your practice may need an appropriate compensation analysis or independent valuation. Avoid determining compensation by saying: “Dr. Smith sends us a lot of business, so she’s worth more.”
Referral value should not be built into your compensation analysis. Instead, examine the value of the services being performed.
Fair Market Value Alone Isn’t Enough
This is a particularly important compliance point.
OIG clarified in April 2026 that an arrangement may still violate the federal Anti-Kickback Statute even when remuneration is consistent with fair market value. OIG explains that fair market value can reduce fraud-and-abuse risk, but it is not a stand-alone guarantee of legality.
That means this isn’t sufficient:
Fair Market Value = Approved
Instead, your review should ask:
Fair Market Value + Legitimate Services + Appropriate Purpose + Proper Structure + No Improper Referral Incentive
Fair market value is part of the analysis, not the entire analysis.
Consider Commercial Reasonableness
Commercial reasonableness asks a related but different question. CMS has defined and clarified commercial reasonableness in the Stark regulations. In practical terms, ask whether the arrangement makes business sense for the organization even without considering the physician’s referrals.
For example, imagine your practice already has three people performing exactly the same medical director function, but management proposes paying a fourth physician $50,000 per year despite having no additional work. Even if $50,000 could theoretically represent fair compensation for a legitimate medical director role, you still need to explain why your organization actually needs another person performing those services.
Ask:
“Would we enter this arrangement if this physician did not refer patients to us?”
If that question makes everyone uncomfortable, investigate further before signing.
Don’t Tie Compensation Improperly to Referrals
Compensation arrangements deserve immediate review when payment increases because the physician sends additional patients or business to the entity. Don’t base compensation on a per-referral, per-click, or similar arrangement when referrals are involved.
OIG’s longstanding guidance on personal services arrangements likewise emphasizes safeguards involving fair market value and compensation that is not determined based on referral volume or value.
Avoid formulas that effectively say: “The more patients you send us, the more we pay you as medical director.”
A medical director should be compensated for legitimate medical director services, not for the physician’s ability to fill your schedule.
Be Careful With Productivity-Based Formulas
Not every variable compensation arrangement is automatically prohibited.
Physician compensation rules are highly technical, and Stark contains specific provisions regarding compensation methodologies. The point for a practice manager is not to assume every bonus is illegal. Instead, unusual compensation formulas should trigger additional review.
If someone proposes a formula that changes based on referrals, collections, downstream revenue, procedures ordered, patients sent to an ancillary service, or another measure that may reflect referral activity, stop before implementing it. Determine whether the methodology is permissible under the specific laws and exceptions that apply.
Make the Actual Work Match the Agreement
A beautifully drafted agreement provides little protection if the relationship doesn’t operate as described.
Suppose the contract says the physician will conduct monthly quality meetings, review policies quarterly, train clinical employees, and complete utilization reviews. A year later, the practice cannot identify a single meeting, policy review, training session, or utilization review the physician performed.
That’s a problem. Your practice needs to monitor both sides of the arrangement:
1. Compensation
Are We Paying What the Agreement Requires?
2. Performance
Is the Physician Performing What the Agreement Requires?
Require Documentation of Services
Create a simple documentation requirement. Depending on the duties, the physician might maintain a monthly activity log, time record, meeting record, report, project summary, policy approval, training record, or other documentation showing the work performed.
Don’t require meaningless paperwork simply to fill a file. The documentation should correspond to the actual responsibilities.
Example: March Medical Director Activities
- Quality committee meeting attended
- Two clinical protocols reviewed
- New staff clinical orientation completed
- Patient-safety incident reviewed
- 6.5 total hours
That type of documentation provides much more support than a monthly check with no record of what was done.
Don’t Backfill Time Records at the End of the Year
If your arrangement requires service documentation, collect it contemporaneously. A physician attempting to reconstruct 12 months of activities the day before an audit is far less reliable than a consistent monthly process. Build the documentation requirement into your accounts-payable workflow.
For example, the practice could require the physician’s monthly medical director activity record before issuing that month’s payment, if appropriate for the particular arrangement. This makes compliance part of the routine process rather than an annual scramble.
Identify Who Reviews the Physician’s Work
Someone should own the relationship. Depending on your organization, that might be the practice administrator, compliance officer, CEO, physician owner, department leader, or another appropriate person.
That individual should periodically confirm that the physician is performing the expected responsibilities and that the services remain necessary. Don’t let the arrangement operate indefinitely because nobody wants to question a physician’s monthly payment.
Include a Defined Term and Renewal Process
Medical director agreements should have a process for determining when the arrangement starts, when it ends, and how it is renewed.
A renewal shouldn’t be treated as a clerical formality. Use it as a compliance checkpoint. Before renewing, ask:
- Does the practice still need these services?
- Are the responsibilities still accurate?
- Is the physician actually performing them?
- Is the compensation methodology still appropriate?
- Has the physician’s referral relationship changed?
- Have applicable laws or regulations changed?
- Does the arrangement still satisfy the Stark or Anti-Kickback analysis supporting it?
A contract renewal is an ideal time to find problems before another term begins.
Address Changes in Duties or Compensation
Medical director arrangements often evolve. A physician may take on a new service line, reduce hours, begin overseeing additional locations, or stop performing certain responsibilities.
Don’t allow the written contract to drift away from reality. Material changes in services or compensation should trigger review to determine whether an amendment or new agreement is needed and whether the compliance analysis should be revisited.
Evaluate Stark and Anti-Kickback Separately
A physician medical director arrangement can potentially implicate both laws.
Stark Law
For Stark, your analysis may focus on whether there is a physician compensation relationship, referrals for designated health services payable by Medicare, and an applicable exception.
Anti-Kickback Statute
For Anti-Kickback, the question may include whether remuneration is being offered or paid with prohibited intent to induce or reward federal healthcare program business.
Do not assume:
Stark Compliant = Anti-Kickback Compliant
OIG specifically cautions that even fair-market-value arrangements may still present Anti-Kickback concerns depending on the facts and intent.
The DIRECTOR Test
Use the DIRECTOR Test before approving or renewing a medical director agreement.
D — DUTIES: Are the physician’s responsibilities specifically defined?
I — IDENTIFIED NEED: Can the organization explain why the medical director position is necessary?
R — RATE: Can you support how compensation was determined?
E — EVIDENCE: Can you prove the physician actually performs the services?
C — COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS: Does the arrangement make business sense independent of referrals?
T — TIED TO REFERRALS?: Does compensation improperly change based on referral volume or value?
O — OTHER LAWS: Have you considered both Stark and Anti-Kickback requirements, along with applicable state law?
R — REVIEW: Is there an established process for monitoring and periodically reevaluating the arrangement?
If you can’t answer one of those questions, address it before the agreement is approved.
Real Practice Example
A multispecialty practice pays one of its physicians $4,000 per month to serve as medical director of a new ancillary service. The agreement was signed several years ago and describes the physician’s responsibility simply as providing “medical oversight.”
During an internal compliance review, the administrator asks what that means. Nobody knows.
The physician doesn’t submit activity records. There is no defined number of hours, no list of responsibilities, and no documentation explaining why $4,000 per month was selected. The physician also refers a significant number of patients to the ancillary service.
Rather than assuming that the existence of a signed contract solves the problem, the practice conducts a more careful review. The revised process becomes:
Identify Need → Define Responsibilities → Analyze Compensation → Review Stark/AKS → Execute Agreement → Document Work → Monitor → Reassess at Renewal
The practice now has a medical director relationship that reflects actual work rather than simply a recurring payment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a Medical Director Agreement Have to Be in Writing?
The exact Stark requirements depend on the exception being relied upon and the specific facts of the arrangement. From a practical compliance standpoint, however, your practice should maintain clear written documentation of a medical director relationship rather than relying on an informal verbal arrangement.
The agreement should accurately reflect the services, compensation, parties, and other important terms.
Can We Pay a Medical Director a Flat Monthly Amount?
Potentially, depending on how the arrangement is structured and the applicable requirements.
A flat monthly payment isn’t automatically compliant simply because it doesn’t change from month to month. Your practice still needs to examine the services, fair market value where applicable, commercial reasonableness, referral relationship, and other legal requirements.
Can We Pay a Medical Director for Every Patient They Refer?
That type of arrangement should immediately raise compliance concerns.
Payments based directly on referral volume can create significant Stark and Anti-Kickback risk. The compensation should reflect legitimate services rather than simply rewarding the physician for generating business.
Is Fair Market Value Enough to Protect the Arrangement?
No.
Fair market value may be an important component of the analysis, but OIG specifically stated in 2026 that fair-market-value remuneration can still potentially violate the Anti-Kickback Statute depending on the facts, circumstances, and intent of the parties.
What If the Physician Isn’t Performing the Duties in the Agreement?
Investigate the discrepancy rather than ignoring it. Determine what services are actually being performed, whether compensation remains appropriate, and whether the arrangement needs to be amended, suspended, corrected, or reviewed with healthcare counsel.
Don’t continue making payments indefinitely for services your organization cannot demonstrate were provided.
Warning Signs Your Medical Director Arrangement Needs Review
Take a closer look if your agreement simply says “provide medical director services,” the physician receives a recurring payment but nobody can identify the work performed, or the practice cannot explain how compensation was determined.
Other warning signs include compensation that increases with referrals, no documentation of medical director activities, an agreement that expired years ago but payments continue, services that no longer match the contract, and a physician who appears to be paid substantially more than others performing comparable responsibilities without a documented reason.
You should also investigate arrangements where management says, “We need to keep this physician happy because they send us a lot of patients.” That sentence should never be your compensation methodology.
Medical Director Agreement Compliance Checklist
Before the Agreement
In the Agreement
During the Arrangement
Before Renewal
Bottom Line
A medical director agreement should document a legitimate service relationship—not provide a convenient label for payments to a physician.
Define the actual responsibilities, explain why the organization needs them, establish and support appropriate compensation, document the work performed, monitor the relationship, and reevaluate it at renewal.
The Strongest Process
Need → Duties → Compensation Analysis → Compliance Review → Written Agreement → Performance → Documentation → Monitoring → Renewal Review
Most importantly, don’t assume that a signed agreement, a fair-market-value opinion, or a legitimate medical director title automatically eliminates Stark or Anti-Kickback risk.
The agreement needs to make sense on paper and in practice.
Key Takeaways
- Put the medical director arrangement in writing.
- Clearly identify the physician and entity entering the agreement.
- Define the medical director’s actual responsibilities rather than using a vague job title.
- Establish a legitimate business need for the services.
- Specify how compensation will be calculated and paid.
- Evaluate whether compensation is consistent with fair market value when required.
- Consider whether the arrangement is commercially reasonable.
- Avoid compensation structures improperly tied to the volume or value of referrals.
- Make sure the physician actually performs the contracted services.
- Require documentation that supports the work performed.
- Monitor the arrangement after signing instead of treating the contract as a one-time compliance exercise.
- Evaluate Stark and Anti-Kickback requirements separately when both may apply.
Get More Practical Compliance Guidance With an All-Access Pass
Medical director arrangements are only one of the financial relationships your practice needs to monitor. Physician compensation, leases, ancillary services, vendor arrangements, marketing agreements, copay policies, referrals, billing practices, and other everyday business decisions can also create Stark, Anti-Kickback, False Claims Act, and broader compliance concerns.
With a Healthcare Training Leader All-Access Training Pass, your entire team gets expert-led guidance on healthcare compliance, billing, coding, HIPAA, medical records, reimbursement, credentialing, practice management, HR, and other issues affecting medical practices. Give your managers practical guidance they can use to recognize risks earlier and strengthen compliance before a contract or payment becomes a bigger problem.
Why Trust Healthcare Training Leader?
Healthcare Training Leader has helped more than 68,000 healthcare professionals at 10,000+ practices strengthen their skills and tackle the operational, financial, and compliance challenges they face every day.
Physician financial relationships can involve complicated Stark, Anti-Kickback, compensation, documentation, and contracting requirements. Our expert-led training focuses on turning those complicated healthcare requirements into clear, actionable guidance your team can put to work.
Meet Your Expert
Michael R. Lowe
Michael is board certified in health care law by The Florida Bar. As Managing Partner of Lowe & Evander, P.A., his practice focuses on all aspects of business, corporate, transactional, litigation, regulatory, operational, and administrative matters in the health care law arena.
Emphasizing the representation of physicians and physician group practices, Michael regularly represents clients in litigation, medical records, and HIPAA privacy regulations issues, managed care contracting and reimbursement matters, the preparation, review, and negotiation of physician employment agreements, Medicare/Medicaid fraud and abuse prevention, federal Stark Law matters and analysis, defense and reimbursement issues, ACA matters, medical staff privilege cases, professional licensure and disciplinary actions, voluntary self-disclosure cases, physician-hospital contracts, compliance plan development, and health care regulatory analysis and counseling matters.
Michael’s practice areas also include the representation of hospital medical staff, IPAs, ambulatory surgery centers, durable medical equipment providers, diagnostic imaging centers, hospitals, long-term care facilities, and other health care professionals and providers.
Additional Resources
-
What Is Healthcare Compliance and Why Does It Matter to Physician Practices?
Healthcare compliance affects every part of a physician practice, from patient privacy and documentation to billing and audits. Learn what healthcare compliance means, why it matters, and how...
-
Improve Incentive Payments for Your Value-Based Payer Contracts
Turn your value-based payer contract reporting into ongoing processes that improve patient care and result in higher incentive revenue for your practice. This expert-led online masterclass will show...
-
DOJ WHIP Program: Is Your Practice at Risk?
A billing error, questionable documentation, or employee complaint could put your medical practice under federal scrutiny faster than you expect. The Department of Justice’s new whistleblower program offers...
